Therapy is more than what happens in sessions. The real work is what happens between the sessions.
Many men wonder how to make the most of therapy. As valuable as therapy can be, change doesn’t happen through weekly 50-minute sessions on their own. That would be like taking a cooking class only to rely on microwave meals the rest of the week.
What happens during a session will depend on your therapist and their methods. But regardless of their approaches, many therapists will work with you to figure out how the things that happen in the session will move out of the office and into your broader life. Some will actively assign homework, which may include behavioral experiments — new things to try or ways to challenge yourself — or may include worksheets or instructions for journaling. Other therapists will not directly give you homework but may spend a few minutes at the end of sessions to brainstorm what that day’s work means for your coming week.
Either way, it can be helpful to have an idea of some things you can do between sessions to make the most of your therapy so you’re not just paying to feel better, but making changes to live better. These include:
Reflecting on the session afterward.
Noticing your patterns of thought, emotion, sensation, and behavior.
Observing yourself with curiosity instead of judgment.
Recording your observations.
Experimenting with new approaches.
Practicing skills between sessions.
1. Reflect on the Session Afterward
A lot can happen in a single session, and there may not be time to unpack all of the “a-ha!” moments. Some of the most profound moments in therapy are often subtle and easy to overlook in session but become more powerful when you think about them later. You may have moments during the time between sessions when something clicks into place and makes sense in the broader context of your life.
With trauma-focused approaches like Brainspotting, you may also experience vivid dreams or unexpected emotions as your mind and body continue to process the work.
You reflect by journaling that evening or taking a few minutes after the session in your car to jot down one thing that stuck with you and one question you have for next time. But be on the lookout for the difference between reflection and rumination.
For men who struggle with overthinking and control, it’s easy to fall into the latter by analyzing everything to death or turning the work into one more achievement to pursue. Rumination asks questions like, “What’s wrong with me?” or “Why can’t I get it together?” It spirals endlessly and leaves you feeling worse.
Reflection, on the other hand, asks questions like, “What can I learn from today’s session?” or “How can I apply these insights to my life?” It has an endpoint and generally leaves you feeling clearer — even if it’s clearer about what questions you need to ask your therapist next time.
If you do notice yourself ruminating, write that thought down as something to bring to your next session and set it aside.
2. Notice Your Patterns
The first steps in therapy are often just planting the seeds of awareness. Many people start with a therapist knowing that they have a problem but without knowing how the problem really plays out in their day-to-day life.
I often ask my clients to start by observing themselves as they go through their week with special attention to their reactions and responses to what happens to them. They might add this to their reflections and take notes on what they observe.
There are four important areas I ask clients to be aware of as they start to pay more attention to their patterns of living:
Thoughts
Your thoughts are what you probably think about most when it comes to mental health counseling. For many men seeking therapy, their thoughts are also the most accessible and familiar experiences to pay attention to. Your thoughts may include predictions about the future, critical thoughts like “I’m such a loser,” rigid thoughts like “I must always be perfect” or “I can never admit a mistake,” or constantly replaying things in your head.
Emotions
Men are often told we’re unemotional when, in reality, we’re not typically taught to be as aware of them. We may also be punished or bullied for showing emotions when young. We often receive messages from society about emotions being “weak” or “for girls.” As a result, we get really good at pushing them away or ignoring them.
But you do experience emotions, whether you’re practiced at recognizing them or not. Think about the panic you felt last time someone almost clipped your car in traffic, the anticipation you have looking forward to the weekend, or the rush of excitement watching your favorite sport or playing a video game.
You don’t have to be “emotionally intelligent” or know a lot of feeling words to start noticing your emotions. You just start where you are and pay attention.
Body Sensations
Your physical sensations are also important information. For many men, awareness of emotions begins with awareness of how their body is responding — which may also be a challenge. Many men come to therapy with layers and layers of armor that cut them off from their emotions and even body sensations. This happens for a variety of reasons such as cultural messages, social programming, and past experiences including events from childhood.
Paying attention to your body sensations can be an important way to cultivate greater awareness of how you respond to events. You might start to notice how your stomach drops when you have to turn down someone’s request for help or how your chest tightens when you think your partner is unhappy with you.
Patterns of Behavior
You probably have times when you go about your day on autopilot, like zoning out during the morning commute or scrolling social media when bored. It can be the same when reacting to things like worry, stress, or self-doubt. Your thoughts, emotions, and even sensations hook you and pull you into saying yes when you want to say no, having an extra drink to take the edge off, or blowing up when you’re struggling to be calm.
Noticing these patterns plants the seed of awareness that leads to change. After all, you can’t change a behavior if you’re not aware of it.
3. Observe Yourself With Curiosity Instead of Judgment
Another thing I encourage with my clients is to engage in this observation and noticing with a spirit of curiosity, as if they were scientists collecting data.
All too often, we observe and evaluate ourselves from a very critical viewpoint. This can be especially true if you struggle with anxiety, depression, or other problems because of a vocal and vicious Inner Critic. It may be part of your usual pattern to beat yourself up for perceived flaws or failures — especially when you know you’re trying to change.
Being curious instead of judgmental about yourself can help you step back from your patterns enough to gain a little more objectivity. But this is easier said than done. Some examples of replacing judgment with curiosity include:
Instead of saying, “I did it again. I’ll never change!” ask yourself, “Something pulled me back into that old pattern. What was it that hooked me?”
Instead of telling yourself, “This is too much! I don’t know how to start,” you might frame it as, “Okay, this was too big a step. How can I scale it down to something manageable?”
Instead of thinking, “I hate being so anxious! I wish it would just go away,” try framing it as, “My anxiety is trying to tell me something. How does my mind think it’s protecting me right now?”
By shifting from judgment to curiosity, you begin to learn how to look at your thoughts instead of looking at the world from your thoughts.
This helps you notice what’s going on and gather information to present to your therapist. Which brings us to the next suggestion.
4. Record Your Observations
As helpful as it is to observe your thoughts, emotions, sensations, and behaviors, the impact of those observations is limited if you forget a lot of it by the time you show up for your next session. Keeping a record of your observations can be a great way to jog your memory or have useful talking points when you sit down with your therapist.
Journaling is a classic example of recording thoughts and observations between sessions. The problem for many people, however, is that it can feel like one more chore in an already busy life complicated by the problems that have them going to therapy.
Many therapists have worksheets they like to use to make things simple. For example, I often give my clients a sheet called The Daily Struggle, developed by Russ Harris. This sheet includes spaces for:
Feelings, Sensations, and Triggers – What uncomfortable emotions and sensations did you experience? What was the event that triggered these experiences?
How much did you struggle? – Rated on a scale of 0 to 10, 0 being no struggle and 10 being intense struggle.
How did you respond? – Did you open up and make room for the feelings? Did you use a management technique? Did you avoid something out of fear? Did you get hooked and pulled into behaviors you’re trying to change?
What was the long-term effect of your response? – Regardless of how it felt in the short term, did your response ultimately enhance your life or worsen it?
Another example is the TICES log often used in EMDR. TICES stands for:
Trigger – The specific event or situation.
Image – The mental picture or memory that came to mind.
Cognition – The negative self-talk or belief that occurred in the moment.
Emotion – The primary feeling you experienced.
Sensation & SUDs (Subjective Units of Disturbance) – The physical feeling you had and its intensity on a scale of 0 (lowest) to 10 (highest).
The trick with recording information is ultimately to find what works for you. If journaling isn’t your jam, don’t do it. If worksheets help, go with that.
With modern technology and phones always nearby, many of my clients create a note on their phone where they jot down information. It may be just a few words like a thought, one emotion, one sensation, and their response. I’ve even had some clients create a private Discord server where they’re the only member as a way to have a place to write both on their phone and their computer.
5. Experiment With New Ways of Responding and Living
Once you start to observe how you think, feel, and act, you’ll start to notice the patterns that you tend to follow. You might notice you engage in anxious overthinking, getting irritated at last-minute changes, or taking it on yourself to fix everyone else’s problems.
As these patterns become evident, the work shifts to interrupting them and developing new ways of responding to the things that cause you worry, stress, anger, or sadness.
You and your therapist may do some work in session that is focused on processing and releasing things from your past, such as old wounds and traumas. Your therapist may also help you identify where it would be helpful to change those patterns and teach you skills and techniques that will support those changes.
For example, a therapist who uses Acceptance & Commitment Therapy (ACT) might teach you a technique to help with emotional processing or ways to engage in mindfulness exercises when you’re feeling anxious or angry. Your therapist might also work with you to change some of your actual day-to-day patterns, such as developing a nighttime routine to promote better sleep.
In the spirit of observing yourself with curiosity instead of judgment, it’s helpful to look at these changes as experiments instead of assignments you’ll either complete successfully or fail. While it’s important to give the experiments your best effort, even ones that seem unsuccessful will reveal information that can help you and your therapist understand where things need to change.
6. Practice the Skills You Learn When Things Are Calm
It’s great to learn a breathing technique that helps with anxiety or a cognitive defusion tool to manage anger when you’re in session with your therapist — but it doesn’t do any good if you’re not applying what you learn in your day-to-day life. As your experiments start to create change, it’s important to keep practicing the skills you learn to sustain those changes. Over time, they’ll become second-nature and replace your old habits and ways of reacting.
But it is very hard to practice a new technique or skill when you’re activated and struggling to think clearly. This is why it pays to also practice skills when things are calm or your activation is there but low.
It’s kind of like learning to drive. New drivers often practice in an empty parking lot or on a closed course at a driving school. As they get better, they drive neighborhood streets that are familiar when things aren’t busy. They practice driving in low-stakes situations and continue to improve until they’re ready to take on the highway at rush hour.
In the same spirit, let’s say you and your therapist have been working on a skill called “Noticing and Naming” from ACT to help manage anxiety that leads to irritation and fights with your partner. Your partner reminds you that it’s your turn to do the dishes and you feel a irritated at being reminded. In the past, you would let that irritation turn into resentment, which then built up until you exploded in a remark like, “I know! I’m not a child!” that turned into a big argument.
Instead of waiting until you’re in the middle of the argument to try using Noticing and Naming to calm down, start when the irritation first creeps in and say to yourself, “I notice I am feeling tightness in my chest. I notice I am having the feeling of irritation. I notice I am having a memory of being scolded by my parents when I didn’t do my chores as a child.”
You might even practice such a skill when you aren’t feeling something uncomfortable. You can make this an intentional act. For example, you might practice when sipping your afternoon coffee or tea. You can take a sip and savor the warmth and flavor and practice saying, “I notice I am enjoying the flavor of my drink. I notice I am having a feeling of calm and appreciation. I notice the feeling of warmth in my mouth.”
Practicing between sessions helps you start to make real change in your life rather than just getting good insights in therapy sessions. It also helps you pressure test the skills to find out where they’re working and where you need more guidance from your therapist.
What to Do at Your Next Session
All of the ideas offered above can help you take what happens in the therapy office and carry it out into your life between sessions. But that work will only get you so far if you’re not talking about your observations and experiments with your therapist — and talking with them honestly about what worked and what didn’t.
This can often be hard, especially when you’re struggling or feel like you “failed” at an experiment. It can be embarrassing to admit to your therapist that you didn’t do what you planned to do in the last session or that you tried and your experiment didn’t work out. You might worry that your therapist will judge you or that you’ll hurt their feelings.
But what you experienced and observed between sessions is information that will help you and your therapist identify what worked well, what didn’t, and what needs to be tweaked to better support the changes you want to see. A good therapist will be able to look at this all in perspective and not judge you for what might feel like a failure or setback.
Regarding nonjudgment, you might think that not judging yourself for a perceived failure, setback, or “falling off the wagon” means not holding yourself accountable for your choices and actions. But there’s a difference between taking responsibility for your choices and judging yourself for them.
Judgment says, “I messed up, even though I knew better. I’m a terrible person.”
Accountability says, “I did it again even though I know I want to change. I still have work to do.”
Being honest with your therapist about what’s working and what isn’t between sessions can help put things in perspective and improve what you do during sessions to create lasting change.
When it Feels Like Too Much
If something comes up between sessions that feels like too much, don’t hesitate to reach out to your therapist. You don’ have to hold it all alone until your next session.
If you find yourself really struggling, you can also reach out to the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline by calling or texting 988.
Putting it All Together
Therapy creates the space for processing, gaining insights, brainstorming, and learning and practicing new skills. Taking those insights and skills into the rest of your life outside of sessions is where you start to make the shift from feeling a little better after sessions to creating real change in your life.
Just like with that cooking class, you’ll start to make the shift from microwave meals to truly eating well.
Looking For Therapy That Will Make a Difference?
Ready to try therapy that carries into the rest of your week? Whether you’re struggling with anxiety and stress, big life changes, low self-esteem, or feeling stuck in your head, I offer counseling for men in Fayetteville, Arkansas as well as telehealth sessions across the state. A free, 20-minute conversation will help you get an idea of how my approach can work for you.
Disclaimer: This article is for information purposes only and is not a substitute for therapy, medical advice, legal advice, or other professional advice. Always seek the advice of a qualified professional regarding questions about your own mental health, medical care, legal matters, or other personal circumstances. Every individual's circumstances are unique. Information that may be appropriate for one person may not be appropriate for another. Reading this blog does not constitute a professional-client relationship. While every effort is made to provide accurate and current information, no guarantee is made regarding the completeness, accuracy, or timeliness of the information provided. Any reliance on the information provided is solely at the reader's own risk. MoonPath Counseling, LLC and the author disclaim liability for any loss or damage arising from the use of this information.